Oakdale's Neighborhood Pizzeria
La Supreme Pizza has been the go-to spot on Montauk Highway for fresh, made-to-order pizza, heroes, and Italian dinners. This is what a real neighborhood pizzeria looks like.
La Supreme Pizza | Our Story
On Montauk Highway, Oakdale
We're right on the South Shore, tucked into Lighthouse Commons on Montauk Highway. Locals have known the number — 631-589-5505 — by heart for years.
Made Fresh, Every Order
Nothing sits under a heat lamp here. Every pizza is made to order — you can taste the difference in every slice.
More Than a Slice Shop
Pizza is just the start — we make stacked heroes, Italian dinners, pasta, calzones, stuffed rolls, and more. It's a full Italian-American kitchen.
Feed a Crowd, We've Got You
Hot food trays for parties, family gatherings, or any event where feeding a crowd matters. Call us ahead and we'll take care of the rest.
Showing Up for the South Shore
We joined nearly 200 restaurants in Long Island Pizza Strong to support West Babylon families — and proudly sponsor the CM Performing Arts Center.
